Summus Ventures

Paper-based products as promising substitutes for plastics in the context of bans on non-biodegradables

As a global environmental problem, plastic pollution has attracted worldwide attention. Plastic wastes not only disrupt ecosystems and biodiversity, but they also threaten human life and health. Countries around the world have enacted regulations in recent years to limit the use of plastics. Paper products have been proposed as promising substitutes for plastics, which undoubtedly brings unprecedented opportunities to the pulp and paper industry. However, paper products have some deficiencies in replacing certain plastic products. Research and development to improve paper properties and reduce production costs is needed to meet such challenges.

Keywords: Plastic; Plastic bans; Pulp and paper industry; Paper-based materials

Contact information: a: Tianjin Key Laboratory of Pulp and Paper, Tianjin University of Science and Technology, Tianjin 300457, China; b: Department of Chemical Engineering, Auburn University, Auburn, AL 36849, USA; c: Tianjin Jianfeng Natural Product R&D Co., Ltd., Tianjin 300457, China; *Corresponding authors: sichli@tust.edu.cn; hzd0024@auburn.edu

# Co-first author with the same contribution to this work

Plastics and Plastic Bans

Plastic products have the advantages of light weight, low cost, good ductility, and excellent insulation, which explains why they have been widely used in industry, agriculture, medicine, and other fields (Geyer et al. 2017). Over the past few decades, the production of plastics has experienced rapid growth. It is reported that by 2015, 8.3 billion tons of plastics had been produced in the world; however, of that amount, 6.3 billion tons had become plastic waste (Geyer et al. 2017). The plastic waste has posed a severe and irreversible impact on the global ecosystem and biodiversity (Abel et al. 2017). In order to avoid or alleviate these problems, many countries and regions around the world have successively launched a series of policies and regulations that prohibit, partially prohibit, and restrict the use of plastic products.

These days, the scope of plastic restrictions has gradually expanded from plastic bags to disposable plastic products such as plastic tableware and plastic cups. The limited use of plastic products has prompted many countries to look for environmentally friendly and cost-effective alternatives. At present, materials such as glass, metals, biodegradable plastics, and paper products have been considered as alternatives to plastic products (Eriksen et al. 2018). Among them, paper products have unparalleled desirability of promoting environmental sustainability, since these products are produced from renewable and abundant lignocellulosic biomass, and they have the advantages of recyclability, biodegradability, and low cost.

How Can Paper Be Engineered to Replace Plastics

Although paper products possess many advantages, as mentioned above, they do have limitations when compared to plastics. Thus, it is of great significance for papermakers to promote the development of manufacturing technologies to address the deficiencies of paper products and expand their applications in replacing traditional plastic products. Details will be discussed in the following sections.

Food packaging products

With the implementation of plastic bans, the demand for disposable paper boxes, paper cups, straws, paper bags, paper cans, and other related paper-based products for food packaging will increase, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic period (Liu et al. 2020). However, paper products are normally opaque, porous, and not heat-sealed. They have poor barrier performance against oxygen and water vapor. There are several ways in the industry to ameliorate these drawbacks, one of which is by coating paper with one or more layers of polymer or metal foil. However, such multilayered paper products face recycling problems. Two other popular strategies involve chemical additives, which can be applied either in the course of surface sizing or at the paper machine wet end. However, there are limited options of chemicals for these purposes because of the high safety standards for use in food packaging materials. Notably, a recent editorial by Wan et al. (2020) pointed out that edible additives could be promising alternatives used for cellulosic paper, especially for food packaging applications. The edible additives can be biobased polymers such as starch, carboxymethylcellulose, protein, chitosan, and rosin, as well as mineral particles (e.g. bentonite, calcium carbonate, and silica). These edible additives are expected to be used for both internal and surface applications, which may provide enhanced mechanical strength, water resistance, and barrier properties of the final products.

Molded pulp products

Molded pulp products (MPP) can be made from various natural fibrous materials such as wheat straw, sugarcane, and recycled paper. Due to the advantages of low toxicity and biodegradability, MPP have the potential to replace plastic products in a wide range of fields, including food containers and tableware, electronic product packaging, compostable containers for agricultural seedlings, medical and health products, building materials, and living furniture. However, MPP are susceptible to environmental humidity and moisture because of the hygroscopic nature of cellulose fibers. Getting wet may reduce their structural integrity and storage life. In order to solve this problem, colloidal rosin and wax emulsions are widely used in the industry. In addition, fluorocarbon polymers are usually used in combination with cationic retention aids to impart repellency to low surface tension oils and greasy liquids. However, the above-mentioned chemicals are not environmentally friendly. Thus, developing green and sustainable additives for MPP will be an important research direction in the future.

Shopping bags

The ban of disposable plastic bags will usher in a new growth point for paper shopping bags. However, the high cost and inferior mechanical strength of paper shopping bags are the main hurdles to large-scale replacement of plastic shopping bags. In the paper industry, paper properties can be tailored by wet-end and surface strategies (Fan et al. 2017). For example, the rational use of chemical additives (e.g. alkyl ketene dimer, alkenyl succinic anhydride, rosin) can enhance the water resistance of paper shopping bags. In addition, surface sizing has been demonstrated as an effective way to improve the physical properties of paper, including mechanical strength, surface morphology, barrier properties, and water and oil tolerance (Chen et al. 2017). Further efforts are needed to develop sustainable additives and sizing agents, as well as advanced manufacturing technology to produce high-performance paper for various types of paper shopping bags.

Agricultural mulch

Agricultural mulch is mainly made of plastics such as polyethylene and polypropylene. However, the plastic mulch is not biodegradable and must be removed and landfilled at the end of the growing season, which will cause environmental pollution. Recently, paper-based agricultural mulch has emerged as a promising alternative due to its great biodegradability. To date, many types of paper such as kraft paper, wax paper, and shredded paper have been used as paper mulches. Among them, kraft paper is currently the most widely used paper mulch. However, the paper mulches have several deficiencies such as overly rapid degradation, poor barrier properties, modest mechanical strength, and difficulty in commercial agricultural operations, which limit their large-scale applications. In order to solve these problems, coated papers for use as mulch with various organic resins and plastic coatings such as polyethylene, polyvinyl chloride, polyvinyl acetate, wax coatings, and latex coatings have been developed in recent years (Haapala et al. 2014). However, these coatings still face the biodegradability problem. Therefore, it is of critical importance for papermakers to develop fully biodegradable paper mulches with controllable degradation rate, good barrier properties, and high mechanical strength. Applying pulp refining, suitable chemical additives, and biodegradable sizing agents may be potential strategies to this purpose.

Nanocellulose and self-assembled nanostructures

The rapid development of nanotechnology can open opportunities for the traditional pulp and paper industry. Cellulose nanomaterials, also known as nanocellulose, that can be produced from lignocellulosic biomass have attracted extensive attention due to their unique properties (Du et al. 2019). Recently, self-assembled cellulose nanopaper (CNP) formed from a nanocellulose suspension has been widely studied due to its superior mechanical properties, tunable optical properties, high thermal stability, low thermal expansion coefficient, excellent oxygen barrier, and biodegradability (Miao et al. 2020). CNP has been highlighted as an alternative to traditional plastic. It has broad application prospects not only for packaging but also in the fields of flexible electronics, biomedical devices, and water treatment (Zhao et al. 2020). In addition, nanocellulose can be used as thin coatings for paper products to increase their barrier performance in packaging applications (Hubbe et al. 2017). Intriguingly, a recent study demonstrated that high-performance bulk structural plates (e.g. 320 mm × 220 mm × 27 mm) can be processed from cellulose nanofibers with light weight, excellent strength and toughness, and high thermal dimensional stability (Guan et al. 2020). The assembled plates can be considered as promising substitutes for plastics, ceramics, and metals, making them a strong competitor for the lightweight materials used for automotive and aerospace applications. Related research is expected to provide a variety of high-performance and environmental-friendly structural materials to replace plastics in the near future.

Future Opportunities

In the context of plastic bans, paper products can replace many plastic products and have numerous advantages in terms of sustainable development and environmental protection. This makes them promising green packaging materials. The plastic bans may provide unprecedented opportunities for the pulp and paper manufacturers. However, certain paper products (e.g. shopping bags) still have deficiencies such as high cost and inferior mechanical strength. Thus, papermakers need to devote effort to develop advanced manufacturing technologies for the low-cost production of high-performance products. In addition, self-assembled nanostructures from nanocellulose, e.g. CNP and bulk structural plate, show great promise in replacing plastics for high-end applications.

 

References Cited

Abel, D. S. M. A., Kloas, W., Zarfl, C., Hempel, S., and Rillig, M. C. (2017). “Microplastics as an emerging threat to terrestrial ecosystems,” Global Change Biol. 24(4), 1405-1416. DOI: 10.1111/gcb.14020

Chen, G., Zhu, P., Kuang, Y., Liu, Y., Lin, D., Peng, C., Wen, Z., and Fang, Z. (2017). “Durable superhydrophobic paper enabled by surface sizing of starch-based composite films,” Appl. Surf. Sci. 409, 45-51. DOI: 10.1016/j.apsusc.2017.02.201

Du, H., Liu, W., Zhang, M., Si, C., Zhang, X., and Li, B. (2019). “Cellulose nanocrystals and cellulose nanofibrils based hydrogels for biomedical applications,” Carbohyd. Polym. 209, 130-144. DOI: 10.1016/j.carbpol.2019.01.020

Eriksen, M., Thiel, M., Prindiville, M., and Kiessling, T. (2018). “Microplastic: What are the solutions?,” in: Freshwater Microplastics, Springer, Cham, pp. 273-298. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-319-61615-5_13

Fan, J., Li, T., Ren, Y., Qian, X., Wang, Q., Shen, J., and Ni, Y. (2017). “Interaction between two oppositely charged starches in an aqueous medium containing suspended mineral particles as a basis for the generation of cellulose-compatible composites,” Ind. Crop. Prod. 97, 417-424. DOI: 10.1016/j.indcrop.2016.12.048

Geyer, R., Jambeck, J. R., and Law, K. L. (2017). “Production, use, and fate of all plastics ever made,” Sci. Adv. 3(7), e1700782. DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.1700782

Guan, Q., Yang, H., Han, Z., Zhou, L., Zhu, Y., Ling, Z., Jiang, H., Wang, P., Ma, T., Wu, H., and Yu, S. (2020). “Lightweight, tough, and sustainable cellulose nanofiber-derived bulk structural materials with low thermal expansion coefficient,” Sci. Adv. 6(18), eaaz1114. DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.aaz1114

Haapala, T., Palonen, P., Korpela, A., and Ahokas, J. (2014). “Feasibility of paper mulches in crop production: A review,” Agr. Food Sci. 23, 60-79. DOI: 10.23986/afsci.8542

Hubbe, M. A., Ferrer, A., Tyagi, P., Yin, Y., Salas, C., Pal, L., and Rojas, O. J. (2017). “Nanocellulose in thin films, coatings, and plies for packaging applications: A review,” BioResources 12(1), 2143-2233. DOI: 10.15376/biores.12.1.2143-2233

Liu, K., Wang, H., Liu, H., Nie, S., Du, H., and Si, C. (2020). “COVID-19: Challenges and perspectives for the pulp and paper industry worldwide,” BioResources 15(3), 4638-4641.

Miao, C., Du, H., Parit, M., Jiang, Z., Tippur, H. V., Zhang, X., Liu, Z., Li, J., and Wang, R. (2020). “Superior crack initiation and growth characteristics of cellulose nanopapers,” Cellulose 27, 3181-3195. DOI: 10.1007/s10570-020-03015-x

Wan, J., Qian, X., Zhang, M., Song, S., and Shen, J. (2020). “Edible additives & cellulosic paper,” BioResources 15(2), 2114-2116.

Zhao, D., Zhu, Y., Cheng, W., Chen, W., Wu, Y., and Yu, H. (2020). “Cellulose-based flexible functional materials for emerging intelligent electronics,” Adv. Mater. 2000619. DOI: 10.1002/adma.202000619

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

scatter hitam
mahjong ways
ufabet
m98
lottovip
u31
w69
cat888
h25
dk7
fun88
ib888
betflix
pigspin
wing1688
pk789
huc99
z8
edmbet
818king
kubet
pgzeed
superslot
bk8
dafabet
m358
riches888
funny888
168galaxy
d55
z16
lottorich28
188bet
dooball
omg333
ufa191
xoslotz
gclub
zbet911
uspin88
bet365
460bet
masurebet
p6
jinda55
hotwin888
vsc888
riches888pg
sbfplay
betflik789
pgslot99
pxj
slotxoth
miami1688
hengjing168
1ufabet
4x4bet
g2g168p
ezslot
pigusso168
gic88
wm55
sushi555
ufa888
3xbet
m88
davin888
ufabet168
ufa100
love928
bgame777
m168
beo777
ufa007
va999
99ruay
siam99
ap123
get77
ufa25hr
ubet89
ufa800
thailotto
siam855
okcasino
orcbet
ipro999
zabbet168
lion123
lv224
lonpao
123goal
slot1234
beo89
goatbet888
ufa656
123win88
tiger444
slot666
pay69
neptuxe
kingkongxo
nexobet
rocket878
ufacam
swag789
nemoslot
betup88
fast168
123faz
beo555
riches666
naza789
rome789
winner191
pigpg
we88
omg369
12bet
ufa356
ktv789
member999
genie168
mgmint
1xbet
faz123
tgapower
livewin22
fafa365
ivip9
easyslot
ufa777
regenbet
lsm99
superwinway
lyn98
happyluke
ufabet369
lava900
w2bet
meowpung
vegasautowin
ufa600
superbonus888
betmw168
ajm789
thewin888
ufabetwin
fafa666
sb888
123vip
k9win
uea8
lockdown168
123cash
tiger88
22fun
wink123
tiger101
sabai999
osaka789
ktv888
pgneko
ak189
aw8
ktv365
ize555
hotbet
luckatron
dumbo12345
d199
m4king
22win
superslot1234
pgzeed168
flix333
bkkgaming
sfbet88
nazaking
123play
zeegame
ssc4
lucabet365
bcr99th
jw8
82pg
goodbet711
dg grand
super pg 1688
58bet
8x8bet
ufa14k
gambit777
hubjoker888
xo666
ufaapollo
miami90
betflix355
oxybet147
akaflix789
ninja999
salalot
ufavision
combo999
sbobet888
royal558
666pg
askmebet
fafa456
beo998
dolfin88
super168
gembet99
hubpgslot
kingkong pg
pgcash
m4super
fafa178
ufa7777
em199
siam123
ezcasino
ize999
ufamax24
bigbet44
g2g4s
mgm99win
eu9
superbet
99football
amb44
7betcity
bmplus
jaspal189
gxy888
avawin
tgagrand
ufa911
mc888
newgen777
one2t168
rpg888
pakyok789
betflik1188
ufaball77
usa88pro
winstarclub
88hourwin
star911
ufabet1212
slot888
richkub
lavacomplex88
ramenclubz
pok49
betflix249
tgaslot
scb9
venom888
betflix2k
ufa333
a88casino
aba444
naza
kub168
wowgame432
fafa678
black168
imba88
ufaname
candy789
osaka888
settee bet
betflix365
tgabet22
ric168
step2bet
sw789
daisy678
hotlive1688
mindset168
nova88max
pg999
n8
pg candy
atm68
betflik6666
ufabnb
ufabet8888
dgs888
boots88
autosbet
wingame99
edm88bet
saclub7
789diamond
atm89
luckyking888
creek168
63luck
naza619
ogbet89
123lucabet
push888
allure168
alpha88
zuka168
first168
siam789
scg9
area88bet
betplay569
sudpung168
lionth
butterfly69
wowslot888
ufa24
ufafat
themaxrich
topbet
wm787
3dbet
nextspin711
utah168
gaga55
mia88
abm888
metabet4u
goldens888
mvpfun88
sagame168th
zolo99
seabet333
guccibet
goatbet90
jingjai1688
heng189
betflikza
shark66
789pro
goallion
kc9
full1688
c9bet
lava55
elio168
foryou1688
funny18
betluckmak
ufax7
pgzeedgame
pg168k
amb999
eu168
betflix1150
lisbon365
moo555
kingbar88
ff88win
ufa045
ufabay
miami09
payu168
dubai191
quick888
lava888
lucy888
betflik84
superwin356
betflix3d
tt69bet
flixwinstar
ibet59
jedifun
ak47max
betflik199
ak88inter
thebest168
ledbet789
luckyall99
jumperbet
goatbet678
starwars168
me88
milo555
ufa405
wink789
ufaallin
taokaebet
168plus
hydra24h
ufa8my
betflikco
ufa1919
ctah99
alpha989
kingthai999
db88
goatbet89
edm66
amb188
vak88
allin99sport
betflix789
scb711
soda191
gamezone789
ko789
goatbet168
m4shark
ufaonline
wink168
588ws
alpha888
edmx168
siam66
pg2win
edm333
nemo168
fiwfan888
gt289
betcash29
labet555
pgzeedgold
allin99pg
joker999
99fun
fivem888
123sabuy
bgodgames
nana888
ufa363
ufaover88
nexobets
ufa356s
g2ggo
voltxgame
kabet555
jack998
pung369
betcash285
jcm88
horizon168
suck168
terra999
starzluck
pakyok118
warior88
redbet168
gbx9
gdg25
amb168bet
vip168sa
168private
yak888
betflix91
mtyclub
ledbet1688
imba99
86kub
ufa877
suckbet
british69
fafa138
best444all
paris47
betflix555
ufa7bet
suki555
123u2
eco879
nigoal2499
podum888
tgabet54
pgrabbit
tiger8899
pigg88
tga357
betflix9s
betflik678
sagame350
ladyclub777
naza4k
tiger1688
lucabet18
kingmouse999
zeegame168
ezbet007
mgwin289
g2ggod
lavacomplex168
ufamcity88
zamba55
paotung999
zoey89
atbet99
1688goatbet
winner599
kpn68
blackbet
asha88bet
allone789
ssgame350
ufabet987
goatbet777
edm99u
gmz789
go9bet
circus
acash888
cwalk88
tmh168
tgabet65
mcity88
winstar999
spicy99x
pvp888
rwc666
betflixfin
euro88bet
vince999
ufascr
sauto
1112betting
ufarocket888
yingpla999
goatbet123plus
luckyday168
sungame1688
wink999plus
star9vip
yes8
ufabet888auto
ld356
zeed24hr
naza88win
dallas77
ambking1234
betworld369
t2bbet
shibuya789
ize222
lott8
warpcasino
ize777
bangkok789
ttt88
gts789
gold1668
fin1688
sexygame1688
allin99up
lala55
168pgplay
wink555
betflik4u
siamufabet
superheng1688
chobbet
kenya777
168cosmo
pg888g
ragga789
ezlotto
lucabet369
punpro777
ufa85auto
lava66th
rich89bet
ambking168
ufa88bet
siamfun
wink888plus
g2gmagic
ufafuture
percy888
ekings
mexma88
sexygame992
megavip66
megagame66
ugame99
pung666
whanjeab666
hitspinbet
lyndaman88
zaabet
leo89
ufasuck
superth168
789sexy
ufasexygame
pttbet88
pung1688
luckygame78
ufaclick
fomomax777
tokyo888
hotbet789
mgwin928
888neo
mvpwin666
lavacomplex66
sexypg888
zabbet1
pung999plus
wink365
blue1688
gameclub555
bfg168
star789
ufabet191
apollo168
spinix168
xpro88
ufabomb
hydra888
ufac4
sexygame666
77lotto
lotto432
ufa350
ole777
w88
123bet
th97
meta456
naza99
sierra88
winner98
dinoplay
panda555
faw99
789km
power99
bacon999
auto147
hit789
pg333
tiger711
uok168
leo999
99mb
manga168
megabet
dnabet
365kub
waspbet
e699
god55
gcwin99
38th
gt66
omg777
168pbet
sands999
asia999
gambit888
mega168
tw2x
boss987
gowingo
sacasino
ving999
paris666
hilo789
vodka168
megame1688
veneza789
wowgame009
livewin1688
pp9bet
ufa88s
pgpig
bully168
xpay168
m89
thb168
odin99
fomobet88
beta88
sing168
washington888
ufa2nine
ufafusion
junket789
imi555
kuiper999
luckyfun168
ufabetwins
jarb888
wy88
lava191
rec1688
moopanda888
nagagame
lynking88
ufacat24
th8282
starx888
n93
123cashs
sbt88
spinix888r
luckyc4
r1r888
betflixhero
tangtem168
ufa138
g2g88
metang99
bio898
river28
hilo444
axie789
betflixjoker
thanos999
sbo222
zoom88
royal888
ufa7979
pung24hr
ipzz
pg777
sudyod888
god989
allbet24hr
avg168
luckyking168
wintime999
boba168
london678
nexobet99
mvppr88
siamfun88
topgun777
lcbet168
win999
london168
mawinbet
gicc
myplayvip
sawan888
win1bet
ultrac4
ufa369
ks888
uplay168
r39
wink777
ufo234
betflik68
helen168
copo168
pgth
789bet
24hd
allcasino
dior188
huaydaddy
yehyeh
roman888
lambo98
ea88
goatbet
ufa4k
therock88
pgc4
rm6
fafa168
gspin
gmz999
65bet
123blue
4×4bet
lyn99
99plus
g2goal
lucky135
beer777
569auto
atgame
messifun
bigwin168
ufa81
xxmac
joker2499
suntoza
pgthailand
nextspin
vip365
ufa777m
ufa2you
pretty911
win88
789step
betflix2u
okdbet
paotung
allmaxbet
fan88
betflik
ufa88
pgplay168
evo77
1688sagame
usa567
123plus
beo333
g79g
auto 147
panda1234
i9mm
lucia68
crow789
7xbet
ufacafe
789maxbet
ra365
bi888
taipei999
lucky777
w128
ambbet
nazathai
meslot
mafia88
gb69
wing888
joker123
ufa168
ufa747
kingm4
apollopg
ufawallet777
naza168
myplay
g2g789t
nagaway
slotxo
bombslot42
shabu189
hubpg
lotto88win
pussy888
lottoup
jetbet888
cat88
550ww
megabet333
allin99
sbobet
pg133
wyn168
pgjoker
galaxyauto
xoth
918kiss
betflix168
k689
bet911
123fox
paris99
queenclub
pg888
77bet
slotwallet
brazil999
kingauto
super slot
empire777
ufawallet
wmbet
iconxfun
tgayes
ezrich
jooxfun
ufax24
winstar
sc168
hubslotxo
ufabet
m98
lottovip
u31
w69
cat888
h25
dk7
fun88
ib888
betflix
pigspin
wing1688
pk789
huc99
z8
edmbet
818king
kubet
pgzeed
superslot
bk8
dafabet
m358
riches888
funny888
168galaxy
d55
z16
lottorich28
188bet
dooball
omg333
ufa191
xoslotz
gclub
zbet911
uspin88
bet365
460bet
masurebet
p6
jinda55
hotwin888
vsc888
riches888pg
sbfplay
betflik789
pgslot99
pxj
slotxoth
miami1688
hengjing168
1ufabet
4x4bet
g2g168p
ezslot
pigusso168
gic88
wm55
sushi555
ufa888
3xbet
m88
davin888
ufabet168
ufa100
love928
bgame777
m168
beo777
ufa007
va999
99ruay
siam99
ap123
get77
ufa25hr
ubet89
ufa800
thailotto
siam855
okcasino
orcbet
ipro999
zabbet168
lion123
lv224
lonpao
123goal
slot1234
beo89
goatbet888
ufa656
123win88
tiger444
slot666
pay69
neptuxe
kingkongxo
nexobet
rocket878
ufacam
swag789
nemoslot
betup88
fast168
123faz
beo555
riches666
naza789
rome789
winner191
pigpg
we88
omg369
12bet
ufa356
ktv789
member999
genie168
mgmint
1xbet
faz123
tgapower
livewin22
fafa365
ivip9
easyslot
ufa777
regenbet
lsm99
superwinway
lyn98
happyluke
ufabet369
lava900
w2bet
meowpung
vegasautowin
ufa600
superbonus888
betmw168
ajm789
thewin888
ufabetwin
fafa666
sb888
123vip
k9win
uea8
lockdown168
123cash
tiger88
22fun
wink123
tiger101
sabai999
osaka789
ktv888
pgneko
ak189
aw8
ktv365
ize555
hotbet
luckatron
dumbo12345
d199
m4king
22win
superslot1234
pgzeed168
flix333
bkkgaming
sfbet88
nazaking
123play
zeegame
ssc4
lucabet365
bcr99th
jw8
82pg
goodbet711
dg grand
super pg 1688
58bet
8x8bet
ufa14k
gambit777
hubjoker888
xo666
ufaapollo
miami90
betflix355
oxybet147
akaflix789
ninja999
salalot
ufavision
combo999
sbobet888
royal558
666pg
askmebet
fafa456
beo998
dolfin88
super168
gembet99
hubpgslot
kingkong pg
pgcash
m4super
fafa178
ufa7777
em199
siam123
ezcasino
ize999
ufamax24
bigbet44
g2g4s
mgm99win
eu9
superbet
99football
amb44
7betcity
bmplus
jaspal189
gxy888
avawin
tgagrand
ufa911
mc888
newgen777
one2t168
rpg888
pakyok789
betflik1188
ufaball77
usa88pro
winstarclub
88hourwin
star911
ufabet1212
slot888
richkub
lavacomplex88
ramenclubz
pok49
betflix249
tgaslot
scb9
venom888
betflix2k
ufa333
a88casino
aba444
naza
kub168
wowgame432
fafa678
black168
imba88
ufaname
candy789
osaka888
settee bet
betflix365
tgabet22
ric168
step2bet
sw789
daisy678
hotlive1688
mindset168
nova88max
pg999
n8
pg candy
atm68
betflik6666
ufabnb
ufabet8888
dgs888
boots88
autosbet
wingame99
edm88bet
saclub7
789diamond
atm89
luckyking888
creek168
63luck
naza619
ogbet89
123lucabet
push888
allure168
alpha88
zuka168
first168
siam789
scg9
area88bet
betplay569
sudpung168
lionth
butterfly69
wowslot888
ufa24
ufafat
themaxrich
topbet
wm787
3dbet
nextspin711
utah168
gaga55
mia88
abm888
metabet4u
goldens888
mvpfun88
sagame168th
zolo99
seabet333
guccibet
goatbet90
jingjai1688
heng189
betflikza
shark66
789pro
goallion
kc9
full1688
c9bet
lava55
elio168
foryou1688
funny18
betluckmak
ufax7
pgzeedgame
pg168k
amb999
eu168
betflix1150
lisbon365
moo555
kingbar88
ff88win
ufa045
ufabay
miami09
payu168
dubai191
quick888
lava888
lucy888
betflik84
superwin356
betflix3d
tt69bet
flixwinstar
ibet59
jedifun
ak47max
betflik199
ak88inter
thebest168
ledbet789
luckyall99
jumperbet
goatbet678
starwars168
me88
milo555
ufa405
wink789
ufaallin
taokaebet
168plus
hydra24h
ufa8my
betflikco
ufa1919
ctah99
alpha989
kingthai999
db88
goatbet89
edm66
amb188
vak88
allin99sport
betflix789
scb711
soda191
gamezone789
ko789
goatbet168
m4shark
ufaonline
wink168
588ws
alpha888
edmx168
siam66
pg2win
edm333
nemo168
fiwfan888
gt289
betcash29
labet555
pgzeedgold
allin99pg
joker999
99fun
fivem888
123sabuy
bgodgames
nana888
ufa363
ufaover88
nexobets
ufa356s
g2ggo
voltxgame
kabet555
jack998
pung369
betcash285
jcm88
horizon168
suck168
terra999
starzluck
pakyok118
warior88
redbet168
gbx9
gdg25
amb168bet
vip168sa
168private
yak888
betflix91
mtyclub
ledbet1688
imba99
86kub
ufa877
suckbet
british69
fafa138
best444all
paris47
betflix555
ufa7bet
suki555
123u2
eco879
nigoal2499
podum888
tgabet54
pgrabbit
tiger8899
pigg88
tga357
betflix9s
betflik678
sagame350
ladyclub777
naza4k
tiger1688
lucabet18
kingmouse999
zeegame168
ezbet007
mgwin289
g2ggod
lavacomplex168
ufamcity88
zamba55
paotung999
zoey89
atbet99
1688goatbet
winner599
kpn68
blackbet
asha88bet
allone789
ssgame350
ufabet987
goatbet777
edm99u
gmz789
go9bet
circus
acash888
cwalk88
tmh168
tgabet65
mcity88
winstar999
spicy99x
pvp888
rwc666
betflixfin
euro88bet
vince999
ufascr
sauto
1112betting
ufarocket888
yingpla999
goatbet123plus
luckyday168
sungame1688
wink999plus
star9vip
yes8
ufabet888auto
ld356
zeed24hr
naza88win
dallas77
ambking1234
betworld369
t2bbet
shibuya789
ize222
lott8
warpcasino
ize777
bangkok789
ttt88
gts789
gold1668
fin1688
sexygame1688
allin99up
lala55
168pgplay
wink555
betflik4u
siamufabet
superheng1688
chobbet
kenya777
168cosmo
pg888g
ragga789
ezlotto
lucabet369
punpro777
ufa85auto
lava66th
rich89bet
ambking168
ufa88bet
siamfun
wink888plus
g2gmagic
ufafuture
percy888
ekings
mexma88
sexygame992
megavip66
megagame66
ugame99
pung666
whanjeab666
hitspinbet
lyndaman88
zaabet
leo89
ufasuck
superth168
789sexy
ufasexygame
pttbet88
pung1688
luckygame78
ufaclick
fomomax777
tokyo888
hotbet789
mgwin928
888neo
mvpwin666
lavacomplex66
sexypg888
zabbet1
pung999plus
wink365
blue1688
gameclub555
bfg168
star789
ufabet191
apollo168
spinix168
xpro88
ufabomb
hydra888
ufac4
sexygame666
77lotto
lotto432
ufa350
ole777
w88
123bet
th97
meta456
naza99
sierra88
winner98
dinoplay
panda555
faw99
789km
power99
bacon999
auto147
hit789
pg333
tiger711
uok168
leo999
99mb
manga168
megabet
dnabet
365kub
waspbet
e699
god55
gcwin99
38th
gt66
omg777
168pbet
sands999
asia999
gambit888
mega168
tw2x
boss987
gowingo
sacasino
ving999
paris666
hilo789
vodka168
megame1688
veneza789
wowgame009
livewin1688
pp9bet
ufa88s
pgpig
bully168
xpay168
m89
thb168
odin99
fomobet88
beta88
sing168
washington888
ufa2nine
ufafusion
junket789
imi555
kuiper999
luckyfun168
ufabetwins
jarb888
wy88
lava191
rec1688
moopanda888
nagagame
lynking88
ufacat24
th8282
starx888
n93
123cashs
sbt88
spinix888r
luckyc4
r1r888
betflixhero
tangtem168
ufa138
g2g88
metang99
bio898
river28
hilo444
axie789
betflixjoker
thanos999
sbo222
zoom88
royal888
ufa7979
pung24hr
ipzz
pg777
sudyod888
god989
allbet24hr
avg168
luckyking168
wintime999
boba168
london678
nexobet99
mvppr88
siamfun88
topgun777
lcbet168
win999
london168
mawinbet
gicc
myplayvip
sawan888
win1bet
ultrac4
ufa369
ks888
uplay168
r39
wink777
ufo234
betflik68
helen168
copo168
pgth
789bet
24hd
allcasino
dior188
huaydaddy
yehyeh
roman888
lambo98
ea88
goatbet
ufa4k
therock88
pgc4
rm6
fafa168
gspin
gmz999
65bet
123blue
4×4bet
lyn99
99plus
g2goal
lucky135
beer777
569auto
atgame
messifun
bigwin168
ufa81
xxmac
joker2499
suntoza
pgthailand
nextspin
vip365
ufa777m
ufa2you
pretty911
win88
789step
betflix2u
okdbet
paotung
allmaxbet
fan88
betflik
ufa88
pgplay168
evo77
1688sagame
usa567
123plus
beo333
g79g
auto 147
panda1234
i9mm
lucia68
crow789
7xbet
ufacafe
789maxbet
ra365
bi888
taipei999
lucky777
w128
ambbet
nazathai
meslot
mafia88
gb69
wing888
joker123
ufa168
ufa747
kingm4
apollopg
ufawallet777
naza168
myplay
g2g789t
nagaway
slotxo
bombslot42
shabu189
hubpg
lotto88win
pussy888
lottoup
jetbet888
cat88
550ww
megabet333
allin99
sbobet
pg133
wyn168
pgjoker
galaxyauto
xoth
918kiss
betflix168
k689
bet911
123fox
paris99
queenclub
pg888
77bet
slotwallet
brazil999
kingauto
super slot
empire777
ufawallet
wmbet
iconxfun
tgayes
ezrich
jooxfun
ufax24
winstar
sc168
hubslotxo
ufabet
m98
lottovip
u31
w69
cat888
h25
dk7
fun88
ib888
betflix
pigspin
wing1688
pk789
huc99
z8
edmbet
818king
kubet
pgzeed
superslot
bk8
dafabet
m358
riches888
funny888
168galaxy
d55
z16
lottorich28
188bet
dooball
omg333
ufa191
xoslotz
gclub
zbet911
uspin88
bet365
460bet
masurebet
p6
jinda55
hotwin888
vsc888
riches888pg
sbfplay
betflik789
pgslot99
pxj
slotxoth
miami1688
hengjing168
1ufabet
4x4bet
g2g168p
ezslot
pigusso168
gic88
wm55
sushi555
ufa888
3xbet
m88
davin888
ufabet168
ufa100
love928
bgame777
m168
beo777
ufa007
va999
99ruay
siam99
ap123
get77
ufa25hr
ubet89
ufa800
thailotto
siam855
okcasino
orcbet
ipro999
zabbet168
lion123
lv224
lonpao
123goal
slot1234
beo89
goatbet888
ufa656
123win88
tiger444
slot666
pay69
neptuxe
kingkongxo
nexobet
rocket878
ufacam
swag789
nemoslot
betup88
fast168
123faz
beo555
riches666
naza789
rome789
winner191
pigpg
we88
omg369
12bet
ufa356
ktv789
member999
genie168
mgmint
1xbet
faz123
tgapower
livewin22
fafa365
ivip9
easyslot
ufa777
regenbet
lsm99
superwinway
lyn98
happyluke
ufabet369
lava900
w2bet
meowpung
vegasautowin
ufa600
superbonus888
betmw168
ajm789
thewin888
ufabetwin
fafa666
sb888
123vip
k9win
uea8
lockdown168
123cash
tiger88
22fun
wink123
tiger101
sabai999
osaka789
ktv888
pgneko
ak189
aw8
ktv365
ize555
hotbet
luckatron
dumbo12345
d199
m4king
22win
superslot1234
pgzeed168
flix333
bkkgaming
sfbet88
nazaking
123play
zeegame
ssc4
lucabet365
bcr99th
jw8
82pg
goodbet711
dg grand
super pg 1688
58bet
8x8bet
ufa14k
gambit777
hubjoker888
xo666
ufaapollo
miami90
betflix355
oxybet147
akaflix789
ninja999
salalot
ufavision
combo999
sbobet888
royal558
666pg
askmebet
fafa456
beo998
dolfin88
super168
gembet99
hubpgslot
kingkong pg
pgcash
m4super
fafa178
ufa7777
em199
siam123
ezcasino
ize999
ufamax24
bigbet44
g2g4s
mgm99win
eu9
superbet
99football
amb44
7betcity
bmplus
jaspal189
gxy888
avawin
tgagrand
ufa911
mc888
newgen777
one2t168
rpg888
pakyok789
betflik1188
ufaball77
usa88pro
winstarclub
88hourwin
star911
ufabet1212
slot888
richkub
lavacomplex88
ramenclubz
pok49
betflix249
tgaslot
scb9
venom888
betflix2k
ufa333
a88casino
aba444
naza
kub168
wowgame432
fafa678
black168
imba88
ufaname
candy789
osaka888
settee bet
betflix365
tgabet22
ric168
step2bet
sw789
daisy678
hotlive1688
mindset168
nova88max
pg999
n8
pg candy
atm68
betflik6666
ufabnb
ufabet8888
dgs888
boots88
autosbet
wingame99
edm88bet
saclub7
789diamond
atm89
luckyking888
creek168
63luck
naza619
ogbet89
123lucabet
push888
allure168
alpha88
zuka168
first168
siam789
scg9
area88bet
betplay569
sudpung168
lionth
butterfly69
wowslot888
ufa24
ufafat
themaxrich
topbet
wm787
3dbet
nextspin711
utah168
gaga55
mia88
abm888
metabet4u
goldens888
mvpfun88
sagame168th
zolo99
seabet333
guccibet
goatbet90
jingjai1688
heng189
betflikza
shark66
789pro
goallion
kc9
full1688
c9bet
lava55
elio168
foryou1688
funny18
betluckmak
ufax7
pgzeedgame
pg168k
amb999
eu168
betflix1150
lisbon365
moo555
kingbar88
ff88win
ufa045
ufabay
miami09
payu168
dubai191
quick888
lava888
lucy888
betflik84
superwin356
betflix3d
tt69bet
flixwinstar
ibet59
jedifun
ak47max
betflik199
ak88inter
thebest168
ledbet789
luckyall99
jumperbet
goatbet678
starwars168
me88
milo555
ufa405
wink789
ufaallin
taokaebet
168plus
hydra24h
ufa8my
betflikco
ufa1919
ctah99
alpha989
kingthai999
db88
goatbet89
edm66
amb188
vak88
allin99sport
betflix789
scb711
soda191
gamezone789
ko789
goatbet168
m4shark
ufaonline
wink168
588ws
alpha888
edmx168
siam66
pg2win
edm333
nemo168
fiwfan888
gt289
betcash29
labet555
pgzeedgold
allin99pg
joker999
99fun
fivem888
123sabuy
bgodgames
nana888
ufa363
ufaover88
nexobets
ufa356s
g2ggo
voltxgame
kabet555
jack998
pung369
betcash285
jcm88
horizon168
suck168
terra999
starzluck
pakyok118
warior88
redbet168
gbx9
gdg25
amb168bet
vip168sa
168private
yak888
betflix91
mtyclub
ledbet1688
imba99
86kub
ufa877
suckbet
british69
fafa138
best444all
paris47
betflix555
ufa7bet
suki555
123u2
eco879
nigoal2499
podum888
tgabet54
pgrabbit
tiger8899
pigg88
tga357
betflix9s
betflik678
sagame350
ladyclub777
naza4k
tiger1688
lucabet18
kingmouse999
zeegame168
ezbet007
mgwin289
g2ggod
lavacomplex168
ufamcity88
zamba55
paotung999
zoey89
atbet99
1688goatbet
winner599
kpn68
blackbet
asha88bet
allone789
ssgame350
ufabet987
goatbet777
edm99u
gmz789
go9bet
circus
acash888
cwalk88
tmh168
tgabet65
mcity88
winstar999
spicy99x
pvp888
rwc666
betflixfin
euro88bet
vince999
ufascr
sauto
1112betting
ufarocket888
yingpla999
goatbet123plus
luckyday168
sungame1688
wink999plus
star9vip
yes8
ufabet888auto
ld356
zeed24hr
naza88win
dallas77
ambking1234
betworld369
t2bbet
shibuya789
ize222
lott8
warpcasino
ize777
bangkok789
ttt88
gts789
gold1668
fin1688
sexygame1688
allin99up
lala55
168pgplay
wink555
betflik4u
siamufabet
superheng1688
chobbet
kenya777
168cosmo
pg888g
ragga789
ezlotto
lucabet369
punpro777
ufa85auto
lava66th
rich89bet
ambking168
ufa88bet
siamfun
wink888plus
g2gmagic
ufafuture
percy888
ekings
mexma88
sexygame992
megavip66
megagame66
ugame99
pung666
whanjeab666
hitspinbet
lyndaman88
zaabet
leo89
ufasuck
superth168
789sexy
ufasexygame
pttbet88
pung1688
luckygame78
ufaclick
fomomax777
tokyo888
hotbet789
mgwin928
888neo
mvpwin666
lavacomplex66
sexypg888
zabbet1
pung999plus
wink365
blue1688
gameclub555
bfg168
star789
ufabet191
apollo168
spinix168
xpro88
ufabomb
hydra888
ufac4
sexygame666
77lotto
lotto432
ufa350
ole777
w88
123bet
th97
meta456
naza99
sierra88
winner98
dinoplay
panda555
faw99
789km
power99
bacon999
auto147
hit789
pg333
tiger711
uok168
leo999
99mb
manga168
megabet
dnabet
365kub
waspbet
e699
god55
gcwin99
38th
gt66
omg777
168pbet
sands999
asia999
gambit888
mega168
tw2x
boss987
gowingo
sacasino
ving999
paris666
hilo789
vodka168
megame1688
veneza789
wowgame009
livewin1688
pp9bet
ufa88s
pgpig
bully168
xpay168
m89
thb168
odin99
fomobet88
beta88
sing168
washington888
ufa2nine
ufafusion
junket789
imi555
kuiper999
luckyfun168
ufabetwins
jarb888
wy88
lava191
rec1688
moopanda888
nagagame
lynking88
ufacat24
th8282
starx888
n93
123cashs
sbt88
spinix888r
luckyc4
r1r888
betflixhero
tangtem168
ufa138
g2g88
metang99
bio898
river28
hilo444
axie789
betflixjoker
thanos999
sbo222
zoom88
royal888
ufa7979
pung24hr
ipzz
pg777
sudyod888
god989
allbet24hr
avg168
luckyking168
wintime999
boba168
london678
nexobet99
mvppr88
siamfun88
topgun777
lcbet168
win999
london168
mawinbet
gicc
myplayvip
sawan888
win1bet
ultrac4
ufa369
ks888
uplay168
r39
wink777
ufo234
betflik68
helen168
copo168
pgth
789bet
24hd
allcasino
dior188
huaydaddy
yehyeh
roman888
lambo98
ea88
goatbet
ufa4k
therock88
pgc4
rm6
fafa168
gspin
gmz999
65bet
123blue
4×4bet
lyn99
99plus
g2goal
lucky135
beer777
569auto
atgame
messifun
bigwin168
ufa81
xxmac
joker2499
suntoza
pgthailand
nextspin
vip365
ufa777m
ufa2you
pretty911
win88
789step
betflix2u
okdbet
paotung
allmaxbet
fan88
betflik
ufa88
pgplay168
evo77
1688sagame
usa567
123plus
beo333
g79g
auto 147
panda1234
i9mm
lucia68
crow789
7xbet
ufacafe
789maxbet
ra365
bi888
taipei999
lucky777
w128
ambbet
nazathai
meslot
mafia88
gb69
wing888
joker123
ufa168
ufa747
kingm4
apollopg
ufawallet777
naza168
myplay
g2g789t
nagaway
slotxo
bombslot42
shabu189
hubpg
lotto88win
pussy888
lottoup
jetbet888
cat88
550ww
megabet333
allin99
sbobet
pg133
wyn168
pgjoker
galaxyauto
xoth
918kiss
betflix168
k689
bet911
123fox
paris99
queenclub
pg888
77bet
slotwallet
brazil999
kingauto
super slot
empire777
ufawallet
wmbet
iconxfun
tgayes
ezrich
jooxfun
ufax24
winstar
sc168
hubslotxo